The Steps of a Criminal Trial

A criminal trial is the stage where the prosecution must prove the charge against the defendant. In Ohio, the accused is presumed innocent, and the prosecution bears the burden of proving every element of the offense beyond a reasonable doubt.

Not every criminal case in Cincinnati reaches trial. Some cases end through dismissal, plea bargaining, or other resolutions. When a case does proceed to trial, however, it generally follows a recognizable sequence.

What Happens Before a Criminal Trial Begins?

What Happens Before a Criminal Trial Begins?

Several important steps usually take place before the trial itself.

A defendant is generally arraigned and asked to enter a plea. Ohio law recognizes pleas that include guilty, not guilty, no contest, and not guilty by reason of insanity, among others.

The parties may also exchange evidence through the discovery process. Under Ohio Criminal Rule 16, prosecutors and defendants have reciprocal discovery obligations once discovery is initiated, and those obligations can continue as new information becomes available.

Pretrial hearings may address issues such as the admissibility of evidence, statements made to the police, searches and seizures, or other disputes that could affect what the jury hears.

Is Every Criminal Trial Decided by a Jury?

No. Some criminal cases are tried before a jury, while others are decided by a judge in what is commonly called a bench trial.

Ohio law allows a defendant in a criminal case pending in a court of record to waive the right to a jury trial and instead have the judge decide the case. The waiver must be made in writing, signed by the defendant, and filed with the court. It must also be made in open court after arraignment and an opportunity to consult with counsel.

If the case is tried to a jury, jury selection takes place before testimony begins.

How Does Jury Selection Work?

The attorneys and the judge can question prospective jurors to determine whether they can fairly decide the case. This process is often called voir dire.

Potential jurors may be removed for legally recognized reasons, and the parties may also have a limited number of peremptory challenges, depending on the type of case. Once the jury is selected and sworn, the trial moves to opening statements and evidence.

What Happens During Opening Statements?

Opening statements give each side an opportunity to explain what it expects the evidence to show.

The prosecution generally goes first because it carries the burden of proof. The defense may then give an opening statement or proceed as permitted by the court.

Opening statements are not evidence. They are meant to provide the judge or jury with a framework for understanding the testimony, exhibits, and other evidence that will follow.

How Does the Prosecution Present Its Case?

The prosecution presents its evidence first. 

That may include:

  • Testimony from witnesses
  • Police body-camera or surveillance footage
  • Photographs
  • Physical evidence
  • Phone, computer, or account records
  • Expert testimony
  • Statements allegedly made by the defendant

Defense counsel can cross-examine prosecution witnesses and challenge the reliability, relevance, or admissibility of the evidence.

Does the Defense Have to Present Evidence?

No. A defendant generally has no obligation to present witnesses or other evidence because the prosecution carries the burden of proof.

Depending on the case, however, the defense may decide to call witnesses, introduce records, offer expert testimony, or present other evidence. The prosecution can cross-examine defense witnesses and may sometimes present rebuttal evidence afterward.

Whether a defendant should testify is a case-specific decision that should be made after considering the evidence and potential risks.

What Happens During Closing Arguments?

After the presentation of evidence is finished, both sides may present closing arguments.

The prosecution generally argues first, followed by the defense, with the prosecution permitted to respond because it bears the burden of proof. Ohio law sets out this general order for criminal trials.

Closing arguments allow the attorneys to explain how they believe the evidence should be interpreted. Like opening statements, the arguments themselves are not evidence.

What Instructions Does the Jury Receive?

Before deliberations, the judge instructs the jury on the law that applies to the case.

These instructions can include the elements of the offense, applicable defenses, the presumption of innocence, and the meaning of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. 

Jurors are expected to apply those instructions to the evidence presented during the trial.

How Does the Jury Reach a Verdict?

After receiving instructions, the jury deliberates in private.

In an Ohio criminal jury trial, the verdict must be unanimous. The jury can return a guilty or not guilty verdict and, in some circumstances, may consider a lesser-included offense.

If the jury cannot agree, the court may declare a mistrial. Depending on the circumstances, the prosecution may be able to retry the case.

If the defendant is found not guilty, the prosecution cannot simply retry the same charge because it disagrees with the verdict.

What Happens After a Guilty Verdict?

A guilty verdict does not always lead to immediate sentencing. In some cases, the court will schedule a separate hearing to decide what penalties the defendant will face.

When determining a sentence, the judge may consider the seriousness of the offense, the defendant’s criminal history, and any sentencing requirements under the law. Penalties can range from fines and probation to jail or prison time, depending on the circumstances.

A guilty verdict also does not necessarily mean the case is over. Depending on the situation, the defendant may be able to challenge the verdict or sentence through post-trial motions or an appeal.

Call the Cincinnati Criminal Defense Lawyers at Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers for a Free Consultation Today

A criminal trial can involve far more than simply presenting witnesses to a jury. Evidentiary disputes, constitutional issues, cross-examination, jury instructions, and trial strategy can all affect how the case unfolds.

If you are facing criminal charges in Cincinnati, Suhre & Associates DUI and Criminal Defense Lawyers can review the case, explain the trial process, and discuss the options available to you. Contact the firm to schedule a free consultation at (513) 333-0014 with a Cincinnati criminal defense attorney today.